Movie News

‘The Wind Rises’ Review : More Tales of Earthsea than Ponyo

‘The Wind Rises’ Review : More Tales of Earthsea than Ponyo
Drew Turney

It was with universal sadness Studio Ghibli animation godfather Hayao Miyazaki announced his retirement in late 2013, and that ”The Wind Rises” would be his last film.

Even though Miyazaki is 73, let’s not pass the tissues around just yet – entertainment figures from Kevin Smith to Stephen King have all said they’re chucking it in, but the call of the muse is too strong.

If it is Miyazuki’s final film, it’s far from a low note to out on, but it’s more ”Tales of Earthsea” than ”Ponyo”, ”Howl’s Moving Castle” or the sublime ”Spirited Away”. What makes Studio Ghibli productions isn’t just the eternally child-like outlook and some of the most heartfelt and technically masterful animation on screens. It’s the magical sense of whimsy.

Scenes from across the Ghibli canon (the flooded township in ”Ponyo”, fish swimming lazily in water covering roads and forests, the train steaming across an endless ocean just a few feet deep in Spirited Away) are exquisite in their vision. The animation – as technically brilliant as it is richly warm – does the rest.

That surreality is where both the company and the director shine, but it’s not a big feature in The Wind Rises so if you love it about Ghibli’s other films, you’ll miss it.

Having said all that, the animation is still second to none, and the hand-drawn feel is still a antidote to the likes of Pixar and the American studio efforts (even though Ghibli uses plenty of CGI, every frame seems beautifully hand-crafted). Several scenes of the view out of a moving train show around eight or 10 individual plates moving at different speeds in the background, an effect that embodies everything that’s visually distinctive about animation without trying to look real.

The story is less about fairy tale magic and more about following your ambitions. There are some fantastical scenes, but they’re the dreams and daydreams of Jiro Horikoshi, a near-sighted kid who loves planes and decides as a kid that he wants to be an aeronautical engineer.

After surviving the 1923 Tokyo Earthquake and rescuing a bewitching young woman and her governess, he goes on to university, studies hard and gets a job at Mitsubishi designing fighter planes for the air force.

The plot is almost a standard biopic as Jiro travels across Europe to learn what other government contractors are doing that might pull the Japanese industry out of the doldrums. He stays with Mitsubishi throughout his young life, eventually working on the Zero fighter that gave Japan the edge in Pacific skies during the Second World War.

Circumstances puts Jiro back within the orbit of the young girl he rescued over a decade before and despite the pressure at his job and his part in aviation history, the pair fall in love.

One of the lofty themes woven into the narrative is the idea that the instruments Jiro had dreamed of working on since he was a boy are military in nature. The film never really answers the question of following your dreams to work in a field that makes more efficient killing machines, but it does ask it. Ironically given the running time, it also seems to gloss over everything pivotal that happens to Jiro later in his story, from Japan’s destiny in the war to his personal life.

Ultimately his hero is just as in love with flight as a concept as Miyazaki is. It’s during his dream sequences that he communes with his Ben Kenobi – legendary Italian aircraft designer Caproni, walking along the wings of flying behemoths and musing over the nature of what they do.

Miyazaki has made a personal film about a real figure from actual history, and the work that’s gone into portraying the real-world early 20th century Japan shows. You don’t see many richer depictions of a time and place in any film, let alone an animated one.

”The Wind Rises” feels a little overlong and you’ll be impatient once or twice for the old magic. It’s not quite up to their best, but Ghibli’s best is still a lot higher than most.

Share this story!Share on FacebookShare on TumblrShare on StumbleUponTweet about this on TwitterEmail this to someoneShare on Google+Pin on PinterestDigg thisBuffer this pagePrint this pageShare on LinkedIn
(Visited 13 times, 13 visits today)
Movie News
Drew Turney

An Australian-based film critic and celebrity interviewer now based in Los Angeles, California.

More in Movie News

FARGO "The Heap" -- Episode 108 -- Airs Tuesday, June 3, 10:00 pm e/p) -- Pictured: (L-R) Keegan-Michael Key as Agent Budge, Jordan Peele as Agent Pepper -- CR: Chris Large/FX

Key and Peele will end after current season

AshJul 27, 2015
arrives at the 17th annual Hollywood Film Awards at The Beverly Hilton Hotel on October 21, 2013 in Beverly Hills, California.

Michael B. Jordan to star in Just Mercy adaptation

AshJul 25, 2015

Will Smith, Jay Z developing real-life HBO miniseries

AshJul 25, 2015

Veep stars developing college football comedy

AshJul 25, 2015

Our Brand Is Crisis gets awards-season release date

AshJul 25, 2015
Actor Garret Dillahunt arrives at the 2011 Film Independent Spirit Awards at Santa Monica Beach on February 26, 2011 in Santa Monica, California.
2011 Film Independent Spirit Awards - Arrivals
Santa Monica Pier
Santa Monica, CA United States
February 26, 2011
Photo by Steve Granitz/

To license this image (63699099), contact

Garret Dillahunt joins Rounding Third

AshJul 25, 2015
SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA - NOVEMBER 30:  Naomi Campbell poses during a photo call for Australian TV show, "The Face of Australia"  at Carriage Works on November 30, 2013 in Sydney, Australia.  (Photo by Mark Metcalfe/Getty Images)

Naomi Campbell checks in to American Horror Story: Hotel

AshJul 25, 2015

Mission : Impossible – Rogue Nation : The Reviews Are In!

ClintJul 25, 2015

Ant-Man actress nabs tiny role in Masters of Sex

Editorial StaffJul 25, 2015