K.T Simpson
I think we can all agree that history is one fickle mistress, difficult to understand and open to some serious interpretation. A film set in the 1500s isn’t going to be one we all resonate with, and it’s almost impossible to judge the historical accuracy of it – especially when all we have is (admittedly amazing) portraits of the key players.
“Mary Queen of Scots” takes us back to 1569, addressing the conflict between Mary Stuart (Saoirse Ronan) and cousin Queen Elizabeth I (Margot Robbie) and their two countries. Upon Mary’s arrival back to Scotland, she intends to reclaim her rightful throne from Elizabeth, and the conflict becomes a bloody battle of marriage, childbirth, murder, rebellion, betrayal and deceit.
Robbie is a rising star in Hollywood, and though she shines as the Queen of England, Ronan is the real star of as Mary Queen of Scots. The young actress delivers difficult dialogue and intense scenes that while interesting, no one can really relate to. But that is the beauty of a historical film, as I’m sure there’s only so many Hollywood staple rom-coms we can sit through.
Let’s be real here, times were insanely different 500 years ago, so the language and conflicts can be difficult to get your head around, especially if you’re not already familiar with the events of the time. If you’re going in blind, it’s simple enough to work out what’s going on, but even I will admit it took me a while. Language aside, the costumes in “Mary Queen of Scots” are phenomenally done, and there’s not a rogue Apple Watch in sight. Props to the Costume Design department for the incredible job (pun absolutely intended).
The film has been criticized for historical inaccuracies, but really a movie needs the Hollywood treatment to succeed on the big screen. I also find it hard to believe that anyone would have any clue the exact words that were said back in the day, but rather know the basic “plot” – of which has been adapted into “Mary Queen of Scots”.
Apart from the leading ladies, the film has an impressive supporting cast. David Tennant stars as John Knox, a Protestant cleric, and leads a revolution, and both Jack Lowden and Joe Alwyn do a fantastic job as love interests for the Queens. Guy Pearce also excels as William Cecil, advisor to Queen Elizabeth.
Director Josie Rourke has done a beautiful job of bringing this story to screen, and her meticulous detail is very noticeable.
“Mary Queen of Scots” is a beautiful display of shining stars – both in cast and in costume. It’s a nice break away from the Hollywood formula, and whether it’s 100% accurate or not – it’s still a nice little history lesson and a glimpse into life in the 1500s. I’ll stay in the 21st century, thanks.
